It's urkin me

Deleted • 25 June 2011 at 4:57 PM

I'm not posting names, but why is it if someone doesn't like an idea they don't simply disagree, they threaten to quit if said idea is fallowed through?

redstar-fireclan • 25 June 2011 at 4:58 PM

I agree. Ppl (like me once XD) leave if they don't like the idea. I don't do it anymore,tho.

balletninja • 25 June 2011 at 4:59 PM

There are some Ideas, I wouldn't quit if they were applied, even if they were terrible. But the ones I would quit on have some serious flaws.

miomar • 25 June 2011 at 4:59 PM

I have no idea☹️

decks123456 • 25 June 2011 at 5:01 PM

probably because it makes the game not fun anymore, because i guess its the competition they like. (eggbreeding for example) it makes the eggs a LOT less rare and the want for the egg is gone.

also some people trade great offers for some creatures and after the breeding the creatures they traded for become less rare and not worth the trade they traded. (make sense?)

@victoria_egg_storage

Deleted • 25 June 2011 at 5:04 PM

Yeah, but instead of threatening to quit they could debate, but I've seen a person or two [No one in this thread] say only "If this idea is made I'm quitting"

No debate, no nothing

dionaea • 25 June 2011 at 5:05 PM

I dunno, I guess if you're seriously angry/really hate the idea you might say something like that but not go through with it. I've never said something like that, but I was furious when Ian put the Balrogi in the cash shop without giving us some kind of token for our efforts in the halloween plot. I guess the people who are most against ideas are those who are most affected by them, and they may react a bit over the top.

Deleted • 25 June 2011 at 5:11 PM

@dionaea

Yeah, and the mummar thing upset me


But, it's just kinda... un sportsman ship like? It ruins some fun of wishing something could be made, even though some most likely will not be made. It makes people feel bad to just offer a suggestion then someone snaps that if the idea is put through - They'd leave. It would sometimes make the creator feel like the cause of the quitting.

dionaea • 25 June 2011 at 5:18 PM

@victoria_egg_storage

I agree, it's better to fill two pages with arguing about something than just saying "I'll quit". And it's true that it is cruel to the creator of the thread, because sometimes there will be things they simply haven't thought of. Though I think the inevitability of some things can also be annoying, for example I don't like the de-evolution potion at all, but I'm pretty sure it will happen at some point, since you can already change everything else about your creature ☹️

Deleted • 25 June 2011 at 5:26 PM

@dionaea -

I like it, somewhat, but I have my doubts.


I like how you get a second chance

But I don't like how people will manipulate it to make it to a more popular stage [Ie - I like second stage tine's, so I'd trade for a second stage before a third.]



Some people are greedy


Like, if the breeding came to be, most would probably be greedy - which sucks for the rest of us who won't do it for personal gain.

IE - When the Tine's came out, I had almost 10. I gave/traded most away
I gave this girl a Tine and she gave me a roo, even though I told her to keep it [She kept saying how she would feel bad if I didn't take it]


If the breeding thing came out, I'd probably keep one of the eggs I'd bred and give the other to a friend/someone I know who wouldn't quit or let it die

But, some people say they would quit if this came through