[updated June 13th!] 🍓 Buying food items, paying extra! 🌽

heatherm19 • 6 February 2026 at 7:13 AM

Was keeping this list on a creature, finally got it fully updated and into a thread! Separated by shop, all 3 food shops in one thread, it's fairly long. Bolded the ones I need most of.
Paying a flat 5k ec extra per item to make it easy! 😊

General Food Store

Sparkling Diamond Sub (4 more)

Emerald Gem Burger (3 more)
Strawberry Caution Tape Roll (6 more)
Mixed Fruit Caution Tape Roll (5 more)
Happy Purple Carrot Kazoo (6 more)
Edible Blue Painted Egg (6 more)
Gold and Copper Coin Skewers (5 more)
Gold and Silver Coin Skewers (6 more)

Lime Sky Gelatin (6 more)
Dark Red Caramel Apple (2 more)
Red Caramel Apple (3 more)
Yellow Caramel Apple (3 more)
Frozen Grapes Cube (4 more)
Frozen Orange Cube (7 more)

Leek Potato Thanksgiving Soup (3 more)
Blueberry Cayni Cotton Candy (4 more)
Marionberry Cayni Cotton Candy (2 more)
Mixed Berry Cayni Cotton Candy (3 more)
Strawberry Cayni Cotton Candy (5 more)
Rainbow Sugar Glass (4 more)
Original Sugar Glass (5 more)

Club Sandwich (5 more)
Hay Sandwich (5 more)
Tomato Sandwich (5 more)
Regular Sand Wich (6 more)
Bowl of Butter Chicken Curry (8 more)
Bowl of Vindaloo Curry (5 more)

White Harvest Basket (6 more)
Blue Dragold Gummy Tail (6 more)
Raspberry Gummy Burger (1 more)
Lime Gummy Burger (6 more)
Lime Krusdot Gummy (5 more)
Celebratory Black Bun Mini-burger (3 more)
Plain Edible Snowball (5 more)
Strawberry Drizzled Edible Snowball (3 more)

Dotted Witches Pot (7 more)
Spider Witches Pot (7 more)
Dark Green Candy Cane Bunch (7 more)
White Mixed Flower Salad (3 more)
Yellow Mixed Flower Salad (3 more)
Yellow Flesh Watermelon Salad (3 more)

Pepperoni Heart-Shaped Pizza (7 more)
Sweet Gingerbread Man (7 more)
Silver Steampunk Croissant (6 more)
Red Top Rainbow Jelly (4 more)
Volcano Hot Sauce (5 more)

Bakery

Chocolate Chunk Cake (4 more)
Dark Chocolate Chunk Cake (5 more)
Orange Chocolate Chunk Cake (2 more)
White Chocolate Chunk Cake (6 more)
Green Bauble Sugar Cookie (8 more)
Red Bauble Sugar Cookie (5 more)

Berry Lava Cake (6 more)
Chocolate Lava Cake (6 more)
Red Velvet Lava Cake (3 more)
Carnivorse Biscuit (5 more)
Blue Vinyl Party Cake (6 more)
Purple Vinyl Party Cake (6 more)
Yellow Vinyl Party Cake (4 more)

Cyan Winter New Year Cake (5 more)
Gold Winter New Year Cake (7 more)
White Winter New Year Cake (5 more)
Emerald Gem Pie (4 more)
Dark Fall Biscuits Set (3 more)
Light Fall Biscuits Set (6 more)
Red Fall Biscuits Set (3 more)
Yellow Fall Biscuits Set (5 more)

Chocolate Dog Biscuits (8 more)
Vanilla Dog Biscuits (5 more)
Chocolate Skelly Biscuits (6 more)
Dark Chocolate Skelly Biscuits (6 more)
Pumpkin Skelly Biscuits (7 more)

Regular Beach Cheesecake (5 more)
Sunrise Beach Cheesecake (6 more)
Blue Beach Cheesecake (5 more)
Lime Patrick Cupcake (2 more)
Banana Patrick Cupcake (6 more)
White Icing St. Patrick's Cake (7 more)
Vanilla St. Patrick's Cake (4 more)
Chocolate Icing St. Patrick's Cake (6 more)

Chocolate 8th Birthday Cake (5 more)
Blue 8th Birthday Cake (7 more)
Grape Witch Hat Cupcake (7 more)
Lime Witch Hat Cupcake (3 more)
Blue Earthquake Cookies (5 more)
Green Earthquake Cookies (6 more)
Red Earthquake Cookies (7 more)
White Earthquake Cookies (6 more)

Assorted Pastel Candy Eggs (3 more)
Assorted Spring Candy Eggs (6 more)
Assorted White Candy Eggs (5 more)
Blueberry Oozing Cupcake (5 more)
Sour Lime Oozing Cupcake (6 more)
Sour Strawberry Oozing Cupcake (6 more)

Blueberry Linzer Cookie (6 more)
Chocolate Raspberry Linzer Cookie (7 more)
Magenta Square Cupcake (5 more)
Pink Square Cupcake (6 more)
Periwinkle Square Cupcake (6 more)
Pink Luffin Sugar Cookies (5 more)
Purple Luffin Sugar Cookies (4 more)
Red Luffin Sugar Cookies (5 more)

Chocolate Spring Cake (6 more)
Dark Chocolate Amoyrm (6 more)
White Chocolate Amoyrm (6 more)
Red Velvet Cake Slice (5 more)
Burnt Tiger Bread Bun (6 more)
Burnt Tiger Bread Loaf (5 more)
Tiger Bread Loaf (6 more)

Finley's Flavors

Orange Olimpt Ice Cream (5 more)
Pink Olimpt Ice Cream (5 more)
Chocolate Snowman Cone (6 more)
Vanilla Snowman Cone (5 more)
Green Snow Cone Mountain (6 more)
White Snow Cone Mountain (7 more)

Pistachio Three Scoop Gelato (3 more)
Berry Three Scoop Gelato (3 more)
Lemon Three Scoop Gelato (5 more)
Sapphire Ice Cream (3 more)
Ruby Ice Cream (1 more)
Black Steampunk Ice Cream (5 more)
Brown Steampunk Ice Cream (7 more)

Ice Cream Lava Citrus Sorbet (3 more)
Ice Cream Lava Orange & Choco Chip Sorbet (5 more)
Ice Cream Lava Vanilla and Orange Sorbet (5 more)
Black Graveyard Rolled Ice Cream (6 more)
Orange Graveyard Rolled Ice Cream (6 more)
Berry Super Valentine's Dessert (5 more)
Neapolitan Super Valentine's Dessert (7 more)
Diamond Waffle Ice Cream Cone (5 more)

Berry Snow Globe Ice Cream (5 more)
Vanilla Snow Globe Ice Cream (4 more)
Coconut Lime Popsicle (6 more)
Double Blueberry Popsicle (7 more)
Vanilla Ice Ice Cream (6 more)
Fall Chocolate Berry Ice Cream Bowl (5 more)
Fall Vanilla Lemon Ice Cream Bowl (5 more)
St. Patrick's Ice Cream Bowl (6 more)
Orange St. Patrick's Day Ice Cream (4 more)

Chocolate Bean Can Ice Cream (5 more)
Neapolitan Bean Can Ice Cream (6 more)
Vanilla Bean Can Ice Cream (8 more)
Pixelated Chocolate Ice Cream Pop (4 more)
Pixelated Vanilla Ice Cream Pop (6 more)
Bubblegum Wisoki Soft Serve (6 more)

Wormy Mint Ice Cream Cup (5 more)
Wormy Strawberry Ice Cream Cup (6 more)
Wormy Vanilla Ice Cream Cup (5 more)
Soggy Black Umbrella of Ice Cream (7 more)
Neapolitan Autumn Ice Cream (7 more)
Pipared Caramel Frozen Pop (5 more)
Pipared Chocolate Frozen Pop (5 more)
Pipared Vanilla Frozen Pop (5 more)
Mint Tornado Ice Cream (6 more)
Vanilla Tornado Ice Cream (4 more)
Vanilla Tasma Ice Cream (4 more)

heatherm_side • 1 week ago

*bump?* Newly updated list!

vanilla • 1 week ago

hiya! I have quite a few extras of some items you're looking for 😊 Trade #1082038

heatherm19 • 6 days ago

@vanilla Thank you so much! 😊

merit • 6 days ago

@heatherm19

I have 36 items between these two trades:

Trade #1082088
Trade #1082089

They should all be items on your list, but if I got anything wrong or there are any you don't need anymore, let me know!

heatherm19 • 5 days ago

@merit Thank you very much! I think I got the math right, lol

merit • 5 days ago

@heatherm19

Seems good to me! Thank you, and good luck on your food hunt!